Listing Content Analysis Review

dailySale:ebyUS:137362402751 | openai:gpt-5.2

Red Dead Redemption 2 (Xbox One)

Red Dead Redemption 2 for Xbox One shown only by cover art; CIB contents (case, 2 discs, manual) are claimed by metadata but not visually confirmed.

unknown unknown medium review
listing dailySale:ebyUS:137362402751 image 0 listing dailySale:ebyUS:137362402751 image 1

Source reconciliation

Resolved title: Red Dead Redemption 2 (Xbox One) unknown ยท minor_difference

  • No conflicts reported.

Pricing: Only the front cover is shown; discs/manual and exact UPC/variant are not confirmed in photos. Do not use as clean variant pricing evidence unless additional images confirm the actual included components and variant identifiers.

c1 boxed_game probable_known_match

Group
g1
Label
Red Dead Redemption II (Xbox One) package
Game
Red Dead Redemption 2
Platform
Xbox One
Region
NA
Version
NA
Signals
Xbox One green header visible | ESRB Mature 17+ logo visible | Rockstar logo visible | 4K Ultra HD / HDR / Xbox One X Enhanced icons visible on cover
Codes/text
  • rating_mark: MATURE 17+ front cover; image:image:front_cover; ESRB rating mark consistent with US/CA retail release
  • publisher_code: R* (Rockstar logo) front cover; image:image:front_cover; Publisher branding; not a unique variant identifier
Source claims
  • gameTitle: Red Dead Redemption 2 title:title; Red Dead Redemption 2 - Microsoft Xbox One
  • platform: Xbox One product_metadata:platform; Xbox One
  • completeness: includesGame/includesBox/includesManual (CIB) pricecharting:conditionKey/completeness; CIB; completeness: game_box_manual; Disc Count: 2 game discs
  • identifier: UPC: 710425498916, 710425498954, 710425498930 product_metadata:product.upc; 710425498916,710425498954,710425498930
Schema hints
{
  "regionalVariant": {
    "setKind": "standard"
  },
  "variantContent": {
    "assetDescription": "Xbox One packaged game (contents not visually confirmed)",
    "quantity": 1
  },
  "priceProduct": {
    "scopeType": "game",
    "label": "Red Dead Redemption 2 (Xbox One) - unverified contents/variant",
    "schemaType": "not_price_evidence",
    "assetDescription": "Single game listing; only cover art photo provided"
  }
}
Condition
Very Good (listing)
Cond. score
7.0
Score reason
Listing condition states 'Very Good'; photos only show cover art without close-ups of case wear, discs, or manual.
Confidence
0.55
  • image: Front cover for Red Dead Redemption II on Xbox One is shown; no photos of open case/discs/manual. 0.75
  • pricecharting: PriceCharting marks condition CIB and notes 2 game discs, but this is not verified by listing photos. 0.6

c2 case insufficient_evidence

Group
g1
Label
Xbox One keep case (assumed, not shown open)
Game
Red Dead Redemption 2
Platform
Xbox One
Region
NA
Version
NA
Signals
Codes/text
NA
Source claims
  • componentType: case pricecharting:completeness; includesBox: true (CIB)
Schema hints
{
  "regionalVariant": {
    "packaging": "keep_case",
    "setKind": "standard"
  },
  "variantContent": {
    "assetType": "case",
    "assetDescription": "Xbox One keep case (not visually confirmed)",
    "quantity": 1
  },
  "priceProduct": {
    "scopeType": "content",
    "label": "Case (unverified)",
    "schemaType": "component",
    "assetDescription": "Keep case inferred from CIB metadata"
  }
}
Condition
NA
Cond. score
6.5
Score reason
Case presence inferred from CIB metadata; no photos of actual case condition.
Confidence
0.35
  • pricecharting: CIB completeness implies packaging included. 0.55

c3 game_media insufficient_evidence

Group
g1
Label
Game disc 1 (inferred)
Game
Red Dead Redemption 2
Platform
Xbox One
Region
NA
Version
NA
Signals
Codes/text
NA
Source claims
  • component: Disc Count: 2 game discs pricecharting:details.Disc Count; Disc Count: 2 game discs
Schema hints
{
  "regionalVariant": {
    "setKind": "standard"
  },
  "variantContent": {
    "assetType": "game_media",
    "assetDescription": "Xbox One game disc 1 (not visually confirmed)",
    "quantity": 1
  },
  "priceProduct": {
    "scopeType": "content",
    "label": "Game disc 1 (unverified)",
    "schemaType": "component",
    "assetDescription": "Disc inferred from metadata only"
  }
}
Condition
NA
Cond. score
6.0
Score reason
Disc existence inferred; no disc surface/ring-code photos to assess wear.
Confidence
0.32
  • pricecharting: Metadata indicates 2 discs for this product. 0.6

c4 game_media insufficient_evidence

Group
g1
Label
Game disc 2 (inferred)
Game
Red Dead Redemption 2
Platform
Xbox One
Region
NA
Version
NA
Signals
Codes/text
NA
Source claims
  • component: Disc Count: 2 game discs pricecharting:details.Disc Count; Disc Count: 2 game discs
Schema hints
{
  "regionalVariant": {
    "setKind": "standard"
  },
  "variantContent": {
    "assetType": "game_media",
    "assetDescription": "Xbox One game disc 2 (not visually confirmed)",
    "quantity": 1
  },
  "priceProduct": {
    "scopeType": "content",
    "label": "Game disc 2 (unverified)",
    "schemaType": "component",
    "assetDescription": "Disc inferred from metadata only"
  }
}
Condition
NA
Cond. score
6.0
Score reason
Disc existence inferred; no disc surface/ring-code photos to assess wear.
Confidence
0.32
  • pricecharting: Metadata indicates 2 discs for this product. 0.6

c5 manual insufficient_evidence

Group
g1
Label
Instruction manual (inferred)
Game
Red Dead Redemption 2
Platform
Xbox One
Region
NA
Version
NA
Signals
Codes/text
NA
Source claims
  • completeness: includesManual: true (CIB) pricecharting:includesManual/completeness; includesManual: true; completeness: game_box_manual
Schema hints
{
  "regionalVariant": {
    "setKind": "standard"
  },
  "variantContent": {
    "assetType": "manual",
    "assetDescription": "Instruction manual (not visually confirmed)",
    "quantity": 1
  },
  "priceProduct": {
    "scopeType": "content",
    "label": "Manual (unverified)",
    "schemaType": "component",
    "assetDescription": "Manual inferred from CIB metadata only"
  }
}
Condition
NA
Cond. score
6.5
Score reason
Manual presence inferred; no photos to verify inclusion or condition.
Confidence
0.3
  • pricecharting: CIB completeness flags manual included, but listing photos do not show it. 0.55

Unknown candidates

  • Red Dead Redemption 2 (Xbox One) retail variant distinguished by UPC among 710425498916 / 710425498954 / 710425498930 medium
    Multiple UPCs are provided in metadata; listing photos do not show the back barcode to select a specific catalogable variant.
    product_metadata/product.upc lists three possible UPCs

Human review questions

  • Do additional listing images (not captured here) show the open case with both discs and the manual?
  • Is the back barcode/UPC visible to pin the exact retail variant (one of the listed UPCs)?
  • Is this actually the standard edition (not Special/Ultimate/Steelbook) based on case/back text?

Warnings

  • Only a single front-cover image is available; no verification of discs/manual, no barcode/UPC, no case interior, no disc label/ring codes.
  • PriceCharting CIB mapping may be incorrect for this specific eBay listing without photo confirmation.

Reviewer label